Since 2003, the Rescue Lake Simcoe Coalition has brought people together to protect Lake Simcoe. Its history connects local residents’ efforts to protect shorelines and natural areas with a wider movement for legislation, public participation and practical action across the watershed.

Bringing the watershed together

The Coalition was founded in 2003 by community groups concerned about the health of Lake Simcoe. Its early directors brought together leaders from ten residents’ and cottagers’ associations to share knowledge, identify common concerns and advocate for stronger protection.

The founding groups believed that informed and engaged communities needed a greater role in decisions about the lake. Concerns about water quality, development and the loss of natural shorelines showed why action was needed across municipal boundaries.

Local disputes helped shape this conviction. In 2005, the Moon Point Residents Association in Oro-Medonte sought to protect a natural shoreline from estate residential development. Residents retained legal counsel and took their concerns to the Ontario Municipal Board. Although their efforts did not prevent the development, the experience reinforced the Coalition’s call for stronger protections and more effective public participation.

Alongside advocacy, the Coalition developed community stewardship programs. WAVE – Healthy Yards, Healthy Waters, launched in 2004, helped families learn how environmentally responsible lawn and garden care could protect water quality.

Campaign Lake Simcoe

By 2006, the Coalition had joined forces with Environmental Defence and Ontario Nature through Campaign Lake Simcoe. Coalition co-founder Bob Eisenberg helped establish the partnership. Claire Malcolmson was hired by Environmental Defence to manage the campaign for dedicated legislation to protect the lake.

The campaign brought residents’ associations, environmental organizations and volunteers together around a shared goal. Public meetings, community events and the SCOOP on Lake Simcoe newsletter helped inform supporters and build momentum. Outreach included an ice-fishing education initiative with students from Georgian College.

At Queen’s Park, Simcoe North MPP Garfield Dunlop helped advance the call for legislation to protect the watershed. The campaign worked with elected representatives to build support across party lines.

During the same period, Coalition board member Annabel Slaight and Jane Meredith developed a fundraising initiative that grew into the Ladies of the Lake. Their calendars, educational events and community activities attracted widespread attention and brought new supporters into the movement. Their outreach invited people to explore the lake, understand its problems and contribute to solutions. The Ladies of the Lake later merged with the Ontario Water Centre.

From Big Bay Point to a provincial commitment

The proposed resort and marina development at Big Bay Point in Innisfil became a focus of public concern about shoreline development and the adequacy of existing protections. The Innisfil District Association, a Coalition member group, challenged the proposal at the Ontario Municipal Board. The development proceeded, but the dispute strengthened calls for a different approach to protecting Lake Simcoe.

Against this backdrop, Campaign Lake Simcoe and the Ladies of the Lake organized the Lake Simcoe Summit in Barrie in July 2007. With hundreds of residents attending, Premier Dalton McGuinty pledged to introduce legislation to protect the lake if his government was re-elected.

Following the election, that commitment led to the Lake Simcoe Protection Act, 2008. The Lake Simcoe Protection Plan took effect in 2009. Together, they established a dedicated framework for protecting and restoring the watershed, addressing phosphorus pollution, water quality, natural heritage, shoreline protection and other threats.

The Act and Plan were a major achievement for the Coalition and its partners. They demonstrated how local organizing, scientific evidence and sustained engagement with government could help secure lasting public policy.

Coalition leaders also contributed to the policy’s development. Bob Eisenberg, Claire Malcolmson and Annabel Slaight served on the Lake Simcoe Stakeholder Advisory Committee, helping bring community perspectives into the process. Their advocacy emphasized the importance of independent science in shaping the Plan.

Putting protection into practice

After the Act and Plan were adopted, the Coalition helped member groups understand and use the new protections in their municipalities.

Local projects connected policy with practical action. These included a stormwater management installation in Shanty Bay and a volunteer mapping initiative developed by Tim Crooks and Claire Malcolmson. The mapping examined natural heritage protections in Oro-Medonte and the changes associated with the Plan.

This work helped establish an enduring part of the Coalition’s approach: examining what environmental policies protect on the ground, identifying gaps and making the findings accessible to residents and decision-makers.

Renewed advocacy and education

Claire Malcolmson became the Coalition’s first Executive Director in 2018 and served until 2025. During her tenure, the organization undertook campaigns on natural heritage protection, land-use planning, infrastructure and road salt, alongside community outreach and student education.

The Protect Our Plan campaign helped residents understand the Lake Simcoe Protection Plan and participate in decisions about its future. This included preparing communities to contribute to the province’s review consultations in 2020–21. Advocacy on development, natural heritage and pollution also highlighted the importance of implementing the Plan.

With support from the Greenbelt Foundation, the Coalition expanded its environmental policy mapping across the watershed. This research compared protections for natural areas with the Plan’s objectives and supported advocacy for stronger natural heritage policies.

The Coalition supported the Chippewas of Georgina Island First Nation in opposing the proposed Upper York Sewage Solutions project. In 2022, Ontario replaced the proposed Lake Simcoe watershed servicing solution with an approach directing wastewater to the Duffin Creek treatment plant on Lake Ontario. This was an important outcome for the First Nation, the Coalition and others who had opposed the project.

Working with Forbid Roads Over Greenspaces and the Simcoe County Greenbelt Coalition, the Coalition helped organize scrutiny of the Bradford Bypass. This work included government submissions, public meetings, webinars, paddles, hikes and demonstrations. Although the campaign did not stop the highway, it brought public attention to concerns about impact on the watershed.

The Coalition also helped create Stop Sprawl York Region and worked with allies on municipal growth and land-use decisions. That initiative later became the York Region chapter of the Alliance for a Liveable Ontario.

With Water Watchers and other partners, the Coalition helped establish the Ontario Salt Pollution Coalition to raise awareness of road salt’s effects on freshwater and advocate for solutions. Through the Lake Simcoe Defenders program, it also began providing free educational opportunities for students.

These initiatives depended on the contributions of member groups, board members, community volunteers, donors and partner organizations.

Building the next chapter

Jonathan Scott became Executive Director in 2025. A Bradford West Gwillimbury councillor, Chair of the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority, member of the Greenbelt Council and Vice-Chair of Conservation Ontario, he brought experience in watershed governance, public policy and government relations.

In November 2025, the Coalition released Protect Our Plan: From Good Goals to Practical Progress. Building on years of advocacy for the Plan, the report set out 13 recommendations for governments and became the basis for renewed municipal and provincial engagement. In 2026, the Coalition developed a further proposal to reward landowners who protect and restore natural areas along shorelines and streams through property tax incentives.

During this period, the Coalition renewed its Board with leaders bringing experience in municipal government, environmental science, public policy and organizational leadership. A new governance manual, clearer board processes, strategic planning and more structured financial and activity reporting strengthened its oversight. New funding commitments supported increased capacity for research, education, communications and outreach.

This next chapter builds on the work of the Coalition’s founders, volunteers, member groups and partners. Its purpose remains the same: bringing people, evidence and practical solutions together to protect and restore Lake Simcoe.